.
Feedback

Family Loses Friend in Sudden Dog Attack

Family seeks stronger laws on aggressive animals after traumatizing experience.

Brookfield resident Margaret Carcaldi was at work on Monday, March 19, when she received a frantic phone call from her daughter: while walking the family dog, six-year-old Benji, a neighbor’s rottweiler had broken loose and attacked, killing the 14-pound Bichon Frise.

Carcaldi’s two children — daughter age 14 and son age 12 — were taking Benji for a walk around their Tower Road neighborhood at 3 p.m. on March 19, as they did every afternoon. After they rounded the corner of Old Woods Road back onto Tower, they crossed to the opposite side of the street before continuing home, Carcaldi said.

“They would always cross the street because every time they passed the dog would lunge and the leash is long enough for him to get his paws on the street,” she said.

Last Monday, as the children crossed on the west side, the rottweiler lunged and the chain gave way, letting it loose on Benji.

“It got my little boy [the Bichon Frise] in its mouth and ripped him off the leash, then tried to take him back inside the house,” according to Carcaldi, who said that the small dog was killed instantly and only suffered briefly. “He just yelped and didn’t give up a fight.”

The rottweiler finally released the dog after an adolescent resident of 45 Tower Road, the only person home at the time, came outside and coaxed it away with a bone. Carcaldi’s kids scooped up Benji and ran to the neighbor’s home, where they called their mother and .

Police fined the owner $600 and the rottweiler was evaluated by Regional Animal Control officer Audrey McKay, who said in an interview that the dog had no prior history of attacking other animals or showing aggression toward humans.

The rottweiler is “fine with people,” McKay said. “There are some dogs that just do not like other dogs — they’re great with people but really bad with other dogs.”

As this is the first offense, the dog will not be killed. However, “If it broke free again, it would be taken and put down,” McKay said.

Instead, the rottweiler must now be inside the house or in a fenced-in area when not with an owner. It must also be on a leash and wear a muzzle when outside.

Carcaldi said she wishes the laws were more aggressive and has contacted state Rep. David Scribner (R-107) to see what can be done.

“If you’re going to own a vicious dog, I’m going to try to change the laws in Connecticut,” she said, including mandating higher homeowner’s insurance and tougher consequences for offenses.

Carcaldi said the family may eventually get another dog, but they won’t be walking it around the neighborhood.

Jane Gallagher March 27, 2012 at 10:29 am
Dogs are dogs - they have their own call of the wild - it is so sad, the Carcaldi's are my neighbors. Poor sweet Benji. I know first hand about animal nature - my own dogs, females have attacked each other, and ripped into me as I tried to seperated them - the issue, they both love me -and each is trying to protect me from the other, I am their territory so they are territorial, as nature made them that way, and they have strong instincts so it is up to ALL owners to be TRAINED, on how to be the barrier between innocent smaller dogs and larger dogs who are doing the job their owners want... protecting their people : ( it isnt just dogs that hurt dogs - someone ran over my sweet cocker, Lancelot on Old Woods Rd... a very wide road that NOONE should hit a child or a dog on......Cars are just as cruel to our family friends......What laws do we have to punish hit and run drivers who don't even stop to take your pet to the vet after they hit them? Rest in peace sweet Benji and my sweet Lancelot.... may you sing to Michael Buble in heaven....
margaret carcaldi March 27, 2012 at 10:32 am
Unfortunately, this dog has attacked anther dog. One dog wandered over to the rottweiler's house and had his backside bit off and required vet care. That owner did not report the attack because her dog was the one who approached the rotty. Another time the elderly homeowner was out in his yard and looked like he was passing out, possibly haveing a heart attack when a neighbor tried to help but was lunged at viciously by this dog.
Jane Gallagher March 27, 2012 at 10:44 am
There are trainers who can train dogs to not attack - thats the good news! The bad news is that owners are the problem - they are ignorant about owning these pups = they are pups just like all pups == animals that are unloved - underfed.... they will be vicious : ( Just like kids - if they are left to roam the streets without adults who care about them - they become vandals and killers -- you get what you put in -- too bad for the dogs that have owners like these -- what street number is this dog at? I have a small cockapoo - he would get torn apart like Benji - so I would like to keep my distance.....
Jane Gallagher March 27, 2012 at 10:52 am
P.S. The courts did horrible things to my son in Connecticut in a custody matter, and I reached out to David Scribner, even spoke to him personally to help me, against a corrupt court, and corrupt lawyers, to change laws, to protect my son - and he did NOTHING...... he totally ignored my son's situation and the result was that horrible things happened to my son as a result .. noone in this state cares about kids and dogs -- they are the laziest most ineffective goverment officials you can ever imagine -- go for tougher laws against humans not dogs - they should have to be trained and go to classes to train their dogs... find a solution out of love instead of anger - don't take your anger out on the innocent animal - it is the people who need to be held accountable... these goverment officials make HUGE money - they are paid to do NOTHING on our tax dollars and then they pass the buck when children and pets are in danger.... Don't hold your breathe about changing laws in this state
Laura-Marie LoFrumento March 27, 2012 at 10:53 am
Sorry...I wrote this post...not my hubby...apparently he was signed in last to Facebook and it logged into the Patch...here it my posting again:
Well a pitbull got loose in my neighborhood last weekend. Jumped it's electric fence, the owners were not home and left the dog outside. When it jumped the fence, the dog charged after my husband, who was doing yard work, my husband wardered him off with a shovel. Then the dog tried to attack a child on a scooter...any dog and dog walker...I frantically called 911...the dispatcher told me to hang up that the police could not help. He gave me a number to the dog warden...where I left a message and no one called back! So 2 hours later my husband and neighbors telling everyone to get into their house with their children and pets...the owners came home lured the dog back home...nothing was done by the warden or police. It's a shame that an actual vicious attack has to happen before they police or fog warden get involved. What about preventton? This is the 2nd time the dog jumped the fence , the first time it attacked another dog. We were just lucky this time. Hey dog warden...if you are reading this want to give me a call...it's been 2 weeks and your response time is shameful!
Matt Marciniak March 27, 2012 at 12:31 pm
My 5 year old son was bit last summer by a neighbors german sheppard. The dog ran into our yard and bit my son whille he tried to get away. The dog warden did a great job with us.He took the dog to make sure he did not have rabies. He spoke to my son and offered for my boy to see some dogs that are nice so he would not be affraid. Thank you from the Marciniak family
Jane Gallagher March 27, 2012 at 01:07 pm
What is the number of this house - so folks can be warned? I will leave a note in my neighbors mailbox (that is proactive - venting here is not!) I will ask them to please put the dog in the back.... and I can leave Daws trainer card for them to have support fromm a professional.... Jane
r March 27, 2012 at 01:13 pm
I am sorry for the family's loss. The loss of a pet--especially in such a violent and unexpected way--is always terrible. It's unfortunate that the rottweiler broke free from its chain outside and attacked the other dog. However, to label all rottweilers or similar large dogs "vicious" and push for legislation regulating owning or caring for only those specific breeds is not a fair solution. There are rottweilers, shepherds, and other large breeds that are gentle, well-trained, and used for therapy work, etc. The problem lies with owners not properly training, socializing, or caring for their dogs. Dogs of any size or breed can bite and attack. Even small "toy" dogs can be "vicious." Proper training for the dog and for the owners is what should be mandated. Owners--whether in a dog park, in community fields, at sports games, or even in neighborhoods, etc.--should also be cognizant of dogs' boundaries and not letting strange dogs play with each other. (I'm not saying that was the case in this tragedy--I'm saying in general)
I would oppose any breed-specific legislation for this area. It's a slippery slope. What would happen if there was a sudden rash of chihuahua, golden retriever or lab attacks on other dogs and people (and I HAVE seen these dogs bite other dogs and people)? Would they then regulate those "family" breeds? Laws for dogs that have attacked would be fair. Pre-emptive judging is not. CT should not be able to control what dog I can or cannot responsibly keep.
aimee March 27, 2012 at 02:03 pm
I am so sorry for the children that had to witness the attack and death of their poor baby. What a horrible event.
Let me now say that the Rottweiler is not the problem. It's his owners. That dog should not have been tied up outside. Chaining dogs creates possessiveness and agression. The dog needs proper exercise, training and should be in a fenced in area. If you are going to own a large dog that already gets a bad rap for its breed, you have to be responsible and aware of what it is capable of if it does not have the right training and excercise. Getting a dog isn't a novelty - you have to put time and work into them - if you're not interested in doing that then don't get one!
aimee March 27, 2012 at 02:06 pm
Agreed - Breed Specific Legislation is ignorant. It's the humans that are the problem.
Scotty March 27, 2012 at 03:43 pm
Dogs are not the problem. It is the idiot owners who refuse to be responsible dog owners.
My brother was recently mauled by a pit bull, while out walking his dog. Luckily, both he and his dog survived, but both were badly injured. The vet and medical bills were in excess of $3,000. The dog owner received a $60 fine. I am sorry that these kids had to experience this event.
Aaron Boyd (Editor) March 27, 2012 at 05:33 pm
Hey folks,
Had a technical issue this afternoon and the poll on this story was accidentally deleted. Feel free to recast your votes and sorry for the inconvenience.
Kathy March 27, 2012 at 05:45 pm
The traumatic experience these children will now have to learn to live with is just plain wrong! That they have to live in fear of this dog that lives right down the road and will most likely re-live the event every time they pass by the home is wrong! This particular dog (regardless of the breed) violently killed a small defenseless family pet that was on a leash going for an afternoon walk on the opposite side of the road. These children instinctively fought with everything they had to save there beloved family pet and then had to wait in a yard with their bloody, torn apart, dead dog for the police to come. That would be difficult for an adult to do and these were just children. Put yourself in their terrified, grieving shoes. THIS particular dog SHOULD have been put down. It's owners obviously are not responsible enough to care for the dog (especially since this dog had already attacked another dog). At the VERY least the dog SHOULD have been taken from the home until Animal Control was able to confirm the owners were able to comply to all the required guidelines. Lets bring the focus back to THIS particular dog. Once a dog kills, it should be put down. It can not be trusted. Just paying a fine is NOT enough. The punishment does not fit the crime in this case. My thoughts are with the Carcaldi family. I am so very sorry for your loss. I know you loved Benji very much.
Rebecca gelineau March 27, 2012 at 07:13 pm
My heart goes out to this poor family. My beloved bichon -Bailey was taken from me near the same way- by two dogs. Bailey was on a leash in his own yard& the 2 dogs  escaped a broken invisible fence.
Shame  on small towns for dealing with these issues in such a lackadaisical way and same with the laws! After spending any savings I had, on an excellent animal law attorney for countless selectmen meetings - to prevent this  EVER happening again. If the ridicule wasn't enough-my bichon was 12, and called old  and sick by a town  employee, I won't say anymore. In In a last ditch attempt, the owner tried to accuse me of attempting to fight off coyotes, not her dogs-as they attacked Bailey.    Long story short... Cont
Rebecca gelineau March 27, 2012 at 07:14 pm
Long story short many diffterent stipulations were ordered- yhen changed ..finally a four sided six foot stockade fence to be put up ..BUT- 'if it happens agains'..  A IF in a school zone! Preventing this happening again was my only goal.
No-it has not happened again. Nor did a six foot stockade fence get installed. Never once did I ask the dogs be destroyed.  I asked they be adopted  to loving and attentive homes.  I 100%agree with the 'ignorance of people' who do not have the time for their animals.  Finally to this family, witnessing this horrific attack. The vision never leaves your mind. I have  PTSD  frOm this incedent. My house is for sale. Near two  years later-hearing those two dogs bark-sends  shivers up my spine. This is a life changing  event.  Thankful- I found a great  counsilor. By the way, the breeds? Lab and Retriever.  The fence?one piece of six foot stockade-blocking their backyard. I have no idea if the dogs are out there or not. I drive to take a walk -to avoid walking by the house directly across the St. from me.  Mrs. Carcaldi    -If you need any help at all: support,  petitions to change Laws- please contact me. Rebecca Gelineau  W.Brookfield. userfun1261@yahoo Again- I am so very sorry for your family.  
Rebecca gelineau March 27, 2012 at 07:21 pm
Forgive my typo's- previous posting -
But- I am raging mad this has happened AGAIN!.. Especially In front of children! What is it going to take to take this dog issue seriously? Rebecca Gelineau
Elaine K March 27, 2012 at 07:41 pm
I was sorry to hear about this poor little dog getting attacked by this rottweiler. How terrible for the family. I hope they can change the laws on this. They need stricter laws regarding these vicious types of dogs.
I work in the insurance industry and certain dogs send up "red flags" to the insurance companies. Rottweilers, pit bulls, chows are regarded as some of the breeds that come up at the top of the list as being vicious. This homeowner may have trouble getting insurance from now on when his insurance company finds out he's got a vicious dog.
r March 27, 2012 at 08:32 pm
I don't think anyone is saying this tragedy was not horrific, and that the family is not traumatized and suffering greatly. It IS horrible. And I'm sure Brookfield's fine residents are sympathetic. I think some of us commenting, though, are concerned that this tragedy may lead to laws that will unfairly stereotype certain breeds and their owners. I'm basing this on the article's quote "“If you’re going to own a vicious dog, I’m going to try to change the laws in Connecticut,” she said, including mandating higher homeowner’s insurance and tougher consequences for offenses." Mrs. Carcaldi is absolutely entitled to fight for whatever laws she feels are needed, of course. And OFFENSES should be punished. But as shown in a later comment below, the definition of a "vicious" dog needs to be cleared up. "Vicious," as in "THAT SPECIFIC dog has a history of attacking dogs and people"? Or "vicious," as in "a dog in Brookfield or CT who happens to be of a "flagged" breed, even if it has no bad history"?
Again, sympathies to the Carcaldi family. But as this is a local news forum where we can discuss issues that may affect our town, I personally think it's okay to put some focus on what a tragedy like this, and its consequences and aftereffects will mean for Brookfield residents. Particularly as it affects legislation that may dictate dog ownership rules, and possibly mandated increased insurance-rates--which could be imposed on Brookfielders with dogs that haven't attacked.
Cheryl Dee March 28, 2012 at 02:27 am
I agree! This dog should have been put down, immediately. He now has the taste of blood and he will attack again...there is no doubt about it. Normal, gentle dogs, do not attack for no reason! They were on the other side of the road, not even stepping near his property, so he should not have felt threatened or protective. Also, what if that dog attacked those poor kids too? Would the owner still get a slap on the wrist with a fine? I would not feel safe to walk past that house, even if he was on a leash with a muzzle. He obviously has had no training and is not from a loving home. Loving owners do not tie their dogs to trees all day long. They take them for walks on a leash just like poor Benjie was doing, so innocently. It really breaks my heart to even think about the kids having to witness such a horriffic thing and the fear and helplessness they must have felt! I hope there will be justice for Benjie!
Lois Imbriano Barber March 28, 2012 at 02:36 am
I find it insane that a dog who kills unprovoked is not put down after just one offense and that we must wait for a second kill before Society is protected is beyond belief and good common sense. We already know the dog is a killer. We need to change the law. I hope the rottie's owners do the right thing, know the dog cannot be trusted, and put it down so their neighbors need not live in fear. My friendly lab could leap a 6-foot fence. I am so very sorry a cute pet had to die this way, especially in front of the two kids that owned him. My heart goes out to them & their pooch.
Steven DeVaux March 28, 2012 at 10:23 am
Tower Road is a dangerous road, evidently for a number of reasons now.
Art Kerley March 29, 2012 at 04:04 pm
The fact that the two children had to witness their dog being attacked and killed by a neighborhood Rottweiler had to be horrific as it was outrageous. My sympathies go out to the entire family. I hope that the owners of the Rottweiler will realize that their dog is not trustworthy and should be put down. I don't say that lightly as I have had dogs all my life and my trusty Border Collie is under my desk as I write this. The owners need to realize that their dog has demonstrated unprovoked and violent aggression which is likely to occur again and renders him unfit as a family pet in a suburban neighborhood. The fact that the law apparently requires two "incidents" before action is taken, although ludicrous, is to, me irrelevant as the responsibility to do the right thing...and do it now...rests with the owners irrespective of the law.
Lois Imbriano Barber May 31, 2012 at 01:18 am
What ever happened with this killer dog? Does anyone know?
Jane Gallagher May 31, 2012 at 09:42 am
The pound took him and put him down.
Lois Imbriano Barber May 31, 2012 at 10:24 am
Did the pound come and take him? Or did the family voluntarily bring him?
DS June 5, 2012 at 03:50 am
Hawk was a loving dog to my children and we will miss him.
unbelievable June 27, 2012 at 02:23 am
Hawk terrorized Tower Rd. Miss him???? Do you think he liked being tied to a tree 24/7???? You created the aggressive dog he became.....You didn't even know he got loose..that is why he was euthanized....???????????????????????
Jane Gallagher June 27, 2012 at 02:34 am
I am sorry for you and Hawk and our street... This street is unfriendly and not a nice place to live - the people in their overpriced cars with theiir spoiled kids drive to fast - they killed my cat driving too fast and my dog who broke through our invisible fence when he tried to follow us as we went biking - it is the people who need stricter law s - the children and the animals are not safe here - I grew up biking with my dogs - free... and my dogs were safe here 10 years ago.... no more.. now people walk with cameras and take pictures of me and my dogs, if my dogs are off the leash as I bring down my trash,,, sick way to live. We were free once - now we are victims of nasty neighbors who are voyeurs and foes not friends. Welcome to Brookfield.
Kathy Polzin June 27, 2012 at 06:43 pm
If Brookfield is such a horrible place, why don't you move elsewhere? Where you can be free?

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Brookfield Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
John Hawley June 18, 2013 at 06:21 pm
1. Why would you put sidewalks in place until the plan of development is fleshed out and working?Read More Sidewalks are normally one of the last things to go in. 2. Go see the Budget for the Brookfield Schools...that will give you the answer
Carol Chapman June 18, 2013 at 03:13 pm
Laura Dorr 6 hours ago near Newtown via Mobile Good news it looks like Norma is staying in the areaRead More so we will feed her and set the trap this weekend, prayers and keep your fingers crossed we get her!! (via Laura's FB page)
Lisa Foltz Allan June 18, 2013 at 06:37 pm
Please contact me on FB before attempting to "capture" Norma. There are some veryRead More important things you should know/do before trying to trap a dog
Carol Chapman June 18, 2013 at 10:01 pm
Please contact Laura Dorr on FB. She's new at this, apparently, and is planning a trap for Norma.
Jaimie Cura (Editor) June 14, 2013 at 09:06 pm
Thanks Gillian, for sharing these pictures and thanks Firefighter Tim and the rest of the fireRead More department for sharing fire safety tips with local students!