Two Mothers Who Had No Choice: Giving Up Babies For Adoption
Two mothers talk about the effects of placing their babies for adoption.
People who know Tanya Parker say she is a dedicated mother who takes an interest in her daughter's school and activities. As an adult college student, Parker is working hard to become a medical assistant. No longer evident are the scars she suffered when she put her son up for adoption, but it doesn't take much to see that she has struggled with her decision ever since.
“I was 23, 24, when I got pregnant with CJ. I wasn’t married then but I did end up marrying his father,” Parker, 34, said. “Him and I had been together 17 years, on and off. He was my first boyfriend in eighth grade, in middle school in Stamford. He was my first love. I went off to Henry Abbott Technical School, and eight years later we found each other again.”
As a teenager, Tanya and her mother had a difficult relationship so she moved to Brookfield with her aunt. After she graduated, Tanya reunited with her boyfriend and at 23, she became pregnant.
"We went to live with my grandmother, but that didn't work out, so we lived in the car for about two months."
“In 2003, I gave my son up for adoption. It was the hardest thing I’ve ever done. But I was living in a car at the time he was born and CJ's father convinced me to give him up. It just wasn’t the right time. We had lost everything. Life was in bits and pieces, and I was trying to go to school. I gave my son up and when we moved into a shelter, I was pregnant again with my daughter."
In 2005, Tanya married the father of her children, but life did not get any easier. They finally moved into an apartment, but even that was lost when her husband stopped paying the rent and they were evicted.
Patty Parker, Tanya's mother had been through a similar yet heartbreakingly scenario. She had also become pregnant before she was married and had also given up a child for adoption.
However, for Patty there was no peace in the decision. Having been traumatized by giving up her child, Patty advised Tanya against it.
Tanya remembers, “When I gave CJ over and the new parents left, I was fine. I wasn’t crying, I was strong. My worker was surprised. But then when I went to the store, I got out of the car and I went to the back to get the car seat, and there was no car seat there, then I started crying. I went to see Jimmy, my children's father, and I told him he needed to come outside. I said I was forgetting something, and I went in and got CJ's baby blanket, and this bear,” Tanya said, holding up a small blue teddy bear.
“The next day, I was fine,” she remembered. “We had an open adoption, so I started getting letters every month. But on his birthday, I had to find something to do instead of crying. That’s why I’m grateful I’m at school now and I’m busy. But I had a C-section, so I know exactly what time he was born, so it's hard. But I still get the pictures and I can compare him to Jimmy and my daughter.”
“When I gave up my son, it was the hardest thing I ever did, but I did it for him,” Tanya said, maintaining a cheery disposition throughout the interview. “I wanted him to be in a better place. At the time, I thought I shouldn’t have given him up, but I was homeless, I couldn’t take care of my son.”
Tanya has many pictures of CJ, who is now 8, on her phone and around the house, and she talks about him as if he is an active presence in the home. Even her six-year-old daughter talks about meeting him with anticipation. “He will come back when he's older,” she said bravely, but her face became sad and her voice took on a pleading tone as if his absence was still hard to understand. “He's my brudder,” she said.
“I can’t wait to see him,” Tanya said with the anticipation usually reserved for a more imminent occasion. “He still has the blonde hair. I was at the Amos House Shelter when my daughter was born, then I moved into this two bedroom apartment. We all knew we were gonna get through this and just take it day by day. We just decided that we were gonna push through it, and it was hard, but we did it.”
Tanya's mother Patty remained quiet while Tanya described her ordeal, but she finally opened up about her own history with adoption. “Tanya has a sister that’s 5 years older and I’ve never seen her. Doubt I ever will. I gave her up for adoption. I had no job, no home, nothing. I’m from Stamford, and they didn’t want me to see the baby, but I said I had to."
Smiling proudly, Patty said, "And I gave the baby a name, and they kept it; Cindy Marie. But I couldn’t tell you what she looked like. It was so hard back then. I had so much anxiety from not knowing anything about her.”
“They didn’t believe in open adoption back then,” Patty said sadly. “I keep thinking one day I’ll get a knock on the door and it’ll be her. I won’t know what to say except 'I’m sorry.' I was 23 years old, driving school buses. I had a closed adoption, which has no contact. It hurt for quite a long time. I couldn’t watch TV shows in the house because they had kids in them.”
With the dust of the past finally settled, Tanya speaks about her life today. “It’s important to be a good mom. My daughter is everything. I wouldn’t change anything about her. She’s the light of my life. She is the world. She’s my world. Life is good. I’m surprised and shocked that I came out of those bad times. I think I did a pretty good job. My daughter’s proud of me. 'Mommy’s going to school,' she says. She was so happy I got accepted.”
While Tanya and her mother have come to terms with their situation as much as possible, both would agree they were unprepared for the tumult and anxiety of placing their child up for adoption.
"I didn't know when I gave up my son what it meant to be a mother," Tanya admitted. "I had only ever been a daughter. But when I had my daughter, I knew what it meant, and I knew I would not give her up."
Professionals who are involved in adoption are quick to say that adoption is not an easy choice, but that it can induce less guilt than alternatives.
Dr. Stephan P. Herman, M.D., resident of Fairfield County Clinical Associate Professor of Psychiatry at the Weil Cornell Medical College in New York said, “Women who place their children up for adoption are going to feel guilt, but it isn't too different than women who terminate their pregnancies. They should just know there will be complex feelings and they should seek counseling with a professional, a loved one or a close friend.”
Jane Coughlin, an advisor at the Family and Children Agency in Hartford, helped Tanya Parker find the family for her son. “Since adoption has been more user friendly and birth parents are more involved, it's a lot better."
Speaking about the practice of closed adoptions of the past, Coughlin said, "Not knowing what happened to her child, it's too painful to ask of a mother. But these mothers should not feel guilty. Guilt should be reserved for things that are bad, and this is not bad. It is something that should be celebrated and not hidden.”
In Waterbury, Carolyn's Place has a long history of helping unwed mothers find families for their babies. “Giving up a child is a very unselfish love. It's so different than it was. As moms, we always want to know where our children are. It's so important, the idea of being able to interview the families and being able to choose where your baby will go,” Ellen Covallo, director of Carolyn's Place in Waterbury, said.
Having support and acceptance is critical to the healing of a mother faced with such an immense decision, and Tanya has been lucky to have made friends who think the world of her. “I am extremely proud of Tanya,” Robie Barile, Girl Scout leader and Council member, said in a telephone interview.
“She became a Girl Scout leader and has taken on so many positions within the troop. It's amazing how she has taken it upon herself to do so much. She is now on the PTO of her daughter's school. For a single mom who is going to school, making a better life for herself and her child, she has had all of our support. She's had low points and she picks herself back up. Everything she does, she does for her daughter. I think she is phenomenal."
The father of Parker's children has chosen not to be involved in their lives. “I’m surprised how well I maintained my life with all the trouble I went through. I’m stronger now than ever, though. I have to be strong for her," Tanya said, smiling adoringly at her daughter. "I’m being a role model for her and I can’t quit.”
Michelle
8:50 am on Monday, November 14, 2011
I know Tanya personally. She has worked so very hard to overcome obstacles and struggles in her life. She is a delightful woman who has emerged out of the darkness that so many face. I recall her living in her car and the heartbreak I felt for her. She broke free of an unhealthy relationship, impoverished, homeless and lost. She has changed the course of her life. She is a loving, dedicated mother who is working hard to build a career for herself and her family. I commend Tanya for believing in herself when her world seemed dismal. Her world is now bright, full of love. I continue to wish Tanya a beautiful and even brighter future.
Tanya Parker
7:31 pm on Monday, November 14, 2011
thank you michelle
kris
9:17 am on Monday, November 14, 2011
What a touching story! I wish Tanya much success in her future.
Tanya Parker
7:31 pm on Monday, November 14, 2011
thank you kris
i am doing very
Michelle
9:48 am on Monday, November 14, 2011
I would also like to add that I admire Tanya for making the very loving, responsible choice to give up CJ for adoption. Her realism of her struggles at the time and her wanting more for her son is commendable. It is never an easy choice to give up a child for adoption. Tanya wanted a good life for her son, a life she knew she could'nt give at that time. She unselfishing wanted him to have a life of love with caring parents that could give him what she was unable to. Tanya is a great Mom, even greater for making a loving choice.
As an adult woman with an adopted teenage sister....I know my sister's life is full of love, support, patience and kindness. God only knows what my sister's life would have been like if my parents didn't adopt her and open their hearts and home to her.
Adoption is a great option. There are many loving homes who would to welcome a child into their hearts. Whether straight, gay, bisexual, multi-ethnic it just doesn't matter. Adoption is love.
Tanya Parker
7:32 pm on Monday, November 14, 2011
:)
Amy
11:22 am on Monday, November 14, 2011
God bless Tanya and the women like her who make the selfless choice to give their children a better life. They are hardly "giving up" their children; they are giving them a better life. I can't think of any more difficult decision. As the mom of two boys who joined our family through adoption, I am grateful to ladies like Tanya. My sons birthmoms have blessed me with children after my long struggle with infertility and miscarriages.
Tanya Parker
7:32 pm on Monday, November 14, 2011
thank you amy
hope you are good as well
JMS63
11:36 am on Monday, November 14, 2011
Tanya stepped up to the plate and continues to become more educated - which is her job as a citizen of the United States. We are all supposed to become positive contributors to society - not just siphon money and benefits from taxpayers. Use of a condom would have prevented the taxpayers from having to foot the bill for her rent, food, schooling, books, clothes, and another child. I'm sure they are free in shelters - it wouldn't even have cost anything for her to be responsible for her actions - didn't she learn anything from having to give up her child?
onceuponanewtown
12:23 pm on Monday, November 14, 2011
JMS63...Karma has the interesting way of coming around to those who stand in harsh judgement of others to give them a chance to experience first hand the suffering and circumstance for better understanding...you also forgot to be grateful that your mother chose life for you. (I don't see how your comments are in any way a positive contribution to society; perhaps you could use a lesson in good old Christian charity?)
God bless you Tanya for having courage, sharing your story and never giving up!
JMS63
7:11 pm on Monday, November 14, 2011
Harsh judgement? She already gave one baby away and then got pregnant again with the same dirtbag who dragged her down in the first place. Her mother??? Stood by while she made the same mistakes she made as a young woman. No one has learned anything here - its just expect one handout after another from the community....Tanya's mother bears no responsibility - her dirtbag boyfriend bears none - just me -and you- the taxpayers funding her mistakes- one after another.
Observer
12:44 pm on Monday, November 14, 2011
Touching story, but how can this be the top news story in a city of over 75,000 people? Patch is slipping...
Donald Borsch Jr
1:11 pm on Monday, November 14, 2011
Indeed, there are many issues here that can easily be shot-down and scrutinized. However...
At least Tanya did not abort the baby. Adoption beats abortion every single time.
And to JMS63, I would say that I will gladly pay taxes to make sure the Tanyas of my State have a chance. And I'm one of those evil TEA Party folks. Tanya is a success story, in my opinion. That says it all.
JMS63
6:21 am on Tuesday, November 15, 2011
If I could shift my share of taxes for people like this to you, I'd do it in a heartbeat. As you can see from the repeated offenses, continued poor decision making, and continued generations of dysfuction, it doesn't work.
Mary
1:30 pm on Monday, November 14, 2011
uhhmmm, She gives up one child for adoption and then gets pregnant again 2 years later and keeps that one. It seems to me like her life was the same if not worse than when she gave up the 1st child. I'm sorry but I don't see that as a success story. What is the lesson learned there. going to have to agree with JMS63
And also with Observer how is that in the news section?
kathy johnson
2:08 pm on Monday, November 14, 2011
Tanya you are a brave woman of great substance who has overcome much tragedy. Those who judge so harshly are usually people who have lived an unscathed life devoid of any huge catastrophic events. I have found that mostly younger people are quick to judge. Many have never experienced real clinical depression or a mental breakdown that is why they tend to judge others so harshly. The important thing is that Tanya did not choose to abort her child thereby giving CJ a chance to grow up and know God. God bless you Tanya. This was the most news worthy story I have read in a very long time.
Tanya Parker
7:33 pm on Monday, November 14, 2011
thank you kathy
i had never did anything like this
told about my life
Michelle
3:10 pm on Monday, November 14, 2011
There are some truly wonderful, caring and supportive comments on here. Its great to share kindness alike.
However, there are few heartless people who hide behind annonymous tag names who completely lack emapthy and humanity. Not everyone has a perfect life in this perfect bubble of Brookfield. People endure heartache and struggles. Its something to celebrate when someone digs themselves out of the dark trenches of life. Not only working hard for a better future but also giving the gift of parenthood to the adoptive parents. How dare you judge someone who was homeless and has worked to make a better life! Furthermore, to the whiny coward who is complaining about this not being news--shame on you! Get a life! The news in general sensationalizes negative stories everyday...all day long. Its refreshing to hear of a personal story with a happy ending.
Again...thanks to the generous and kind people who share humanity so graciously.
Christine E.
7:08 pm on Monday, November 14, 2011
Michelle with no last name is getting on the case of people who post anonymously? lol
QWERTY
3:16 pm on Monday, November 14, 2011
Why do people support this? I mean, I can't imagine having to give up a child, that in and of itself is traumatic enough, I pray for her..but 2 years isn't enough time to turn one's life around. Why subject another child to this lifestyle? This woman can't seem to get along with her own family. Her mother, grandmother, aunt...why is it so difficult for her to live with kin that should otherwise be an easy scenario? Seems like nothing has been learned or realized here.
Christine Rose
6:36 pm on Monday, November 14, 2011
Everyone has been a teenager, and everyone has made mistakes. Tanya's daughter is five years old, and couldn't be a happier or more loved child. Tanya's mother babysits her granddaughter, and they all get along now.
Tanya Parker
7:36 pm on Monday, November 14, 2011
christine i think that you did a very good job
but got a full comments that i did not like
but i am strong
thank you very much
i have touch a lot of poeple reading this story they learn somthing new about me
so again thank you
keep in touch
Susan Joy
6:38 pm on Monday, November 14, 2011
I am very disappointed in the negative comments and lack of support for the family. If this is not the news you want then skip it and move on. Tanya made the best possible decision given her situations. In two years she was also more mature and had more faith that she could rise to the challenge of raising a child. All three of my daughters are adopted, closed adoptions. I can not imagine how a mom could surrender three such dolls. I hope they all find their birth moms some day in their lives so their birth moms can see how they have turned out . It has to be the hardest decision to make, I can not imagine a harder decision. God Bless Tanya.
Tanya Parker
7:35 pm on Monday, November 14, 2011
thank you susan
MIchael Macchio
7:29 pm on Monday, November 14, 2011
To many people take the easy way out by victimizing the baby. God bless you Tanya! Thank you for choosing life.
Tanya Parker
7:36 pm on Monday, November 14, 2011
thank you michael
Tanya Parker
7:30 pm on Monday, November 14, 2011
thank you to all
doris noel
7:53 pm on Monday, November 14, 2011
Nice story. People need to stop being so judgemental. Good luck to ms.parker and her children. God bless .
Kelley HC
10:36 pm on Monday, November 14, 2011
I applaud Tanya for being brave enough to tell her story. But I have mixed feelings about this article. I hope that teenagers will read this and learn from it. Abstinence and birth control are important issues to discuss if you are having sex.
Lynn F.
10:59 pm on Monday, November 14, 2011
It's hard not to be judgmental due to a persons own experiences themselves or ones around them. I pray Tanya sticks to the road she is on (higher education, loving her daughter & hope she habitually keeps in contact with her son) and stays away from any man who will not help her and admit responsibility for a child. Tanya's story is far from being over, and I can relate to some of the negative comments a few people posted yet I wish her much hope in her life that she can overcome many more obstacles... I raised two children on my own, invested all my love and might in them and I made damn sure they became self sufficient citizens in our society (pretty much so - one receives partial assistance for daycare while she works!!!) My other daughter earns $40,000 a year -she works overtime and whatever odd jobs she can work... Kudos to young people who actually get ahead in life despite their dysfunctional upbringing/lifestyles!!!
Tanya
9:23 am on Tuesday, November 15, 2011
The wackiest thing about this for me is that we have the same name and are the same age! LOL
Tanya
9:23 am on Tuesday, November 15, 2011
Same last name too... :O
Observer
11:53 am on Tuesday, November 15, 2011
The woman can't even put a sentence together in the comments...and she's a success story? She demonstrates absolutely no comprehension of punctuation or grammar...how did she get into any college?
jim laguardia
2:50 pm on Tuesday, November 15, 2011
Observer... not everyone can put together a sentence like you... she may have no comprehension of punctuation...or grammer...but those of us who use "..." so much should...not throw stones...even if those...are not followed by a space??...??
MyGoodPeople
12:23 pm on Tuesday, November 15, 2011
It is unfortunate when people such as Observer feel it is there right to condemn another. How dare you take the holier than thou mentality. You have obviously lived a privileged life without pain or despair. For this I pity you.
This young women has opened her life to us. No one has the right to judge her. Tanya keep on the high road, care for your children and yourself. Those that matter are taking notice of how hard you are working through this difficult time. I for one am very proud of you and the fact that you have shared your story with us.
QWERTY
12:28 pm on Tuesday, November 15, 2011
When her story is used as a news article, people have every right to judge her.
Why does someone need to live a privileged life to know not to have a child when they can't support one?!...let alone TWO children!?
MyGoodPeople
12:40 pm on Tuesday, November 15, 2011
I guess it is because I live by the golden rule "do unto others as you would have them do unto you" that I just assume everyone cares about others.
But since reading the various posts on Patch I have learned that there are too many heartless, self centered, judgmental and special people (at least in their own minds) and that is sad. Shame on any and all who feel superior to another. There will come a day when you to will be judged and may God bless you then.
Tanya Parker
8:51 pm on Tuesday, November 15, 2011
i just whated to say this is the real tanya parker and i can spell thank you very much
and also just whated to say thank you very much for reading and i am very happy that i have told my story and that i am in touch and also get pictures of him and i am willing to send him things for his bday as well as x-mas also
so again thank you very much
JMS63
10:04 am on Wednesday, November 16, 2011
Let's just agree that this article may be appropriate for a "feel good" women's magazine or a self-help workshop - not a news website. The title, however, is misleading. These women were NOT forced into adoption - they chose to have unprotected sex when they had no means to support themselves. If Tanya keeps up with her education AND now gets a job since her mother can babysit, then she will be fulfilling her responsibilites as a contributing member of society. For the love of god -Tanya, start using spellcheck when you publish writing for others to read. Even elementary school students know that you always capitalize "I" when you are writing about yourself. Good grief.
Observer
4:00 pm on Wednesday, November 16, 2011
At least someone gets it.
kathy johnson
4:41 pm on Wednesday, November 16, 2011
For the love of God JMS63 and Observer grow a heart. You may know how to spell but that does not make you a better human being. I do not think that God or any higher power you may believe in cares if Tanya can spell. Two more cowards who hide behind fake names. It may be that Tanya has contributed more to society in many more ways than you know but if you measure a contribution by how much money one earns then I guess you fall short of Bill Gates and if you measure your IQ in relation to Tanya's spelling errors than I guess you fall short of comparing yourself to Einstein or Physicist Stephen Hawking.
kathy johnson
4:50 pm on Wednesday, November 16, 2011
Christmas is coming I suggest that JMS63 and Observer read the Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens or the Rime of the Ancient Mariner by Samuel Taylor Coleridge you may have a change of heart.
kathy johnson
4:52 pm on Wednesday, November 16, 2011
oops I spelled then as than. I better hang my head in shame.
kathy johnson
5:37 pm on Wednesday, November 16, 2011
Tanya I would like to say one last thing to you. Never be sorry that you told your story. Never look too far back at your mistakes and never feel afraid of the future. Do not give in to feeling sad and learn from your mistakes. If you fall on your face pick yourself up again. Take care of your body and your mind. Live in the moment, enjoy your children and be happy they are well and in this world. When I retire next year I want to be an advocate for people who are poor in spirit because of the "slings and arrows of life". I have faced three huge life changing events in my life and learned the hard way how the quality and tranquility of ones life can change in a few seconds even if you are perfect and do all the "right" things. God Bless and be well. Kathy Johnson
JMS63
5:44 pm on Wednesday, November 16, 2011
There is a difference between falling on hard times and making stupid choices and expecting others to not only pay your way but pat you on the back for finally coming around and taking responsibility. Let's choose to move on and drop the sarcasm - which doesn't help anyone - just shows how immature you are - and it is appropriate that you hang your head in shame - at least you went back and reviewed your work!! Good job!!!!
Daniel Patti
6:00 pm on Wednesday, November 16, 2011
If you have nothing good to say don't say anything at all. Unless of course you use a bogus name on Patch to criticize others, nice going.
JMS63
6:58 pm on Wednesday, November 16, 2011
Wow, are you always so profound? Commenting on news articles is not supposed to be all "good" - if you can't take the heat - stick to the "feel good" women's magazines and let the rest of us think for ourselves.
Michelle
6:57 pm on Wednesday, November 16, 2011
Well said, Mr. Patti! I completely agree!
Douglas Brennan
7:41 pm on Wednesday, November 16, 2011
I asked a young man "How are you doing?" He told me that he had personal problems but he couldn't discuss them since they were, after all, "personal" This young man has autisim yet he shared one of the greatest blessings with me; that of wisdom. God Bless the wisemen and the wisdom they bistow on all of us.
bumblin bill
8:14 pm on Wednesday, November 16, 2011
Did these women not have a choice to not get pregnant in the first place?
QWERTY
11:29 pm on Wednesday, November 16, 2011
No one can do anything wrong by you religious nuts. I'm a church going man myself but I'm also big on accountability. If you can't take care of a child, wait until you have children. It's incredibly selfish to have a child and not be able to provide for it.
MIchael Macchio
11:44 pm on Wednesday, November 16, 2011
JMS63 & the other no-name elitists: Accountability and responsibility are important and need to be encouraged, but outside of you perfect atheists, people are human and make mistakes. Fortunately, Tanya made a good decision, tough decision to choose life over an easy way out. If you read the article you will see that Tanya has taken many steps to improve her life and that of her child's. Instead of criticizing her, we should be congratulating her and encouraging others who have made poor choices in the past to learn from their mistakes and make better decisions in the future.
Observer
9:16 am on Thursday, November 17, 2011
Some of you are really thick-headed. I don't care that she can't spell - I'm just curious how it landed her in an institution of higher learning. But, like JMS pointed out, my real concern is that this is a story that belongs in a women's magazine or something - definitely not a newspaper (which I thought Patch was supposed to be). That's the way most of Christine's articles read; I'm not sure why Patch continues to pay her for meaningless cream puff stories like this. Don't get me wrong, they're sometimes interesting and usually well-written, but I'd much rather get some news. Back to newstimes.com.
Christine Rose
9:27 am on Thursday, November 17, 2011
It would be so much better if you identified yourself, Observer. For one thing, the News Times also does feature stories and profiles, and for another, you may well work for them. Thank you for so consistently reading my stories. I am honored.
John F.
10:07 am on Thursday, November 17, 2011
Why the need to call someone to identify themselves? This topic has been discussed ad nauseum on many other posts, and people have their differing valid reasons as to why they do not post their names.
Observer
10:50 am on Thursday, November 17, 2011
It's humorous how off base you are, Christine (especially inferring that I'm employed by The News Times - ha!). I have no reason to give you ANY personal information about myself. Second, like I said, your stories are sometimes interesting and usually well-written - I just don't think they're being used in the right publication. Have you considered submitting to more appropriate venues (serious question)?
Observer
10:54 am on Thursday, November 17, 2011
And yes, of course the News Times publishes features and profiles - but it doesn't dominate their newspaper the way your stories do with Patch. I'm not sure of your relationship with Mark Langlois, but I find it truly shocking that he can't find reporters to cover the actual news that goes on in this city - a few days ago, a freakin' BODY was found in Downtown Danbury...Patch didn't cover the story themselves, but rather just linked to the News Times' article on the matter. Awful, and a poor excuse for community journalism.
Christine E.
1:08 pm on Thursday, November 17, 2011
Personally, I think it's stupid to post a piece of journalism on a highly debatable, touchy subject and then get clearly displeased and annoyed when readers share their opinions about it. Adoption, Abortion, Religion, Politics...all things that will trigger highly emotional responses, both 'pro' and 'con'. Tanya, you opened your life up to the world...now there will be people who say things about you that you might not like. I suggest you get over it, because you made the choice to go public with your personal life.
Christine, you write articles and share them to the world...there will always be people who won't like them. Being defensive and snotty about it isn't going to change it.
MyGoodPeople
9:54 am on Thursday, November 17, 2011
I am not a church going religious person. Although I was raised with values and compassion that were taught by a good family.
This young lady opens her life to us not looking for acceptance or approval but to show that she is trying to turn her life around. Perhaps her story will help another young person.
To all of you heartless, preaching, self-centered and arrogant people, I hope you or a family member never fall on hard times. If you do I hope you find someone who will forgive you for your life's errors. Condemning another is not a good way to live. People are being way too mean and it is not fair, necessary or acceptable. These same people should keep there closets locked so their skeletons do not fall out.
Patch I believe it is time to shut this forum down to prevent further indignation.
QWERTY
2:19 pm on Thursday, November 17, 2011
By "heartless, preaching, self-centered and arrogant people" do you mean successful, responsible and selfless people?
You're asking that this forum be shut down because you're being challenged. When faced with adversity, you can't fold simply because you don't want to deal with the situation at hand. Talk about self-centered...you're demanding that others listen and accept the story at hand without question.
MyGoodPeople
9:29 pm on Thursday, November 17, 2011
Qwerty IF (and that is a large IF) you are successful, that does not give you the right to be heartless, self centered or arrogant and that you ARE.
I have no problem with an intelligent challenge, but truly too many of you folks are just down right mean. This young lady did not open her life and the article was not written for you folks to open fire on her. This is not high school and I am sure you have not been young enough for high school in a long time. At some point in your life you must have been taught to love your neighbor and not judge others.
QWERTY
12:02 pm on Friday, November 18, 2011
People pass judgement every second of their life! You judged me in your reply! Who gives YOU the right?!
I didn't start my child's life going 10 steps backwards, let alone a SECOND child.
MaryAnn Benevenuto
10:06 am on Thursday, November 17, 2011
Success story? I think not. Dating at 13? Perhaps that's why she didn't get along with her mother. Compassion? - if you use your talents and abilities and stop blaming circumstances and hard times. If you are born with a disability such as autism, and you do your best, that is commendable.
MyGoodPeople
10:59 am on Thursday, November 17, 2011
Maryann you have once again proven that you need someone to pray for the heartless cruel person that you are. May your children never have a skip in their step and if they do people like myself will be sure to help them up and tell them it is OK mistakes happen throughout our lives. As long as we learn from them it is OK. We will not forever judge them and you should not as you do not have the right to judge others. =^)
kathy johnson
10:26 am on Thursday, November 17, 2011
I agree shut it down.
Observer
10:56 am on Thursday, November 17, 2011
Feathers are ruffled, we must shut this down! God forbid there exists a forum for challenging discussion!
MyGoodPeople
11:01 am on Thursday, November 17, 2011
Observer challenging is one thing cruelty is yet another!
Hoa Nguyen
11:14 am on Thursday, November 17, 2011
This topic has really generated a lot of comments that have gone well beyond the scope of the story, although related and relevant. We like to encourage people to give their opinions on topics and I think we can all agree that there are many different ones when it comes to what is being discussed. Sometimes the most convincing arguments are the simplest ones that are free from personal attacks.
Observer, please feel free to email Mark Langlois directly at mark.langlois@patch.com or me directly hoa@patch.com if you have any suggestions or concerns about what is presented here. I work for the Newtown site but we work collaboratively in this region and I can refer your inquiry to others at Patch if necessary. Thanks.
kathy johnson
11:15 am on Thursday, November 17, 2011
BRAVO!O
Observer
1:39 pm on Thursday, November 17, 2011
Hoa, thank you for addressing me, but I don't need to e-mail you my concerns...I've made them clear VERY often on this site, on this article and others, and have not heard ANYTHING back from a Patch editor until now. Want my concerns in a nutshell? WHERE IS THE NEWS? This is a city of 80,000+ people. There are at least three high schools in this city AND a university. To habitually run feature stories and "feel-good" pieces that, as JMS pointed out, would be better suited for a magazine-style publication as the top news stories in this city is deplorable, and a sorry excuse for community news. Where is the town government coverage? What about entertainment in and around the city? What about continuous coverage in our schools (Christine's series on overcrowding was FANTASTIC)? What about athletics in both the high schools and the university?
I don't need to point any further than this past week to prove my point: a BODY is found in Downtown Danbury, and Patch doesn't actually produce any content, but just links to The News Times' website. I guess they figured they'd let the real newspaper take care of the real news from here on out. It's a shame, because Patch truly has the capability to bring community journalism to the next level.
Christine E.
1:54 pm on Thursday, November 17, 2011
Observer -
You're going under the assumption that this article is only being published on the Danbury Patch. This is one of those regional articles that gets published on multiple patch sites. But I do agree with you, for the most part.
Hoa Nguyen
2:04 pm on Thursday, November 17, 2011
Hi Observer, I think it would be good to not go too off-topic on these comment boards, which was one of the reasons I suggested you email or phone me 203-816-7613 or Mark 203-209-7371 directly rather than posting it on an article about adoption. We value everyone's opinion and invite debate, but we also don't want to go too far off-topic out of respect for readers and those who comment here interested in the topic at hand. I apologize for doing exactly that in this post, though I believe you deserve a response.
Finally, reading and participating on Patch is a truly voluntary no-cost option, which you would appear to being doing, so obviously you are finding some value in what you see here. Thanks for being a part of Patch.
Observer
2:06 pm on Thursday, November 17, 2011
Christine E. -
Thanks for letting me know that; I didn't realize it. What other sites is it used on? Do they also run these kinds of stories as top news, front and center on the home page? Maybe Danbury's lack of hard news is an isolated issue, and not reflective of Patch as a whole - I don't really check the other sites much.
Christine E.
6:29 pm on Thursday, November 17, 2011
Observer -
I am reading it through Monroe patch, as are many other commenters on this thread. I know that this is also on Newtown Patch and Bethel Patch. I don't know how the region is broken down. I find that it's really easy to notice when an article is regional when I see a large number of responses (compared to local articles) and when I don't recognize many of the names of people who are posting :)
jim laguardia
2:57 pm on Thursday, November 17, 2011
some of you people need help.... observer noticed i used ....oh and this time without a space. This is under the heading of "The Neighborhood Files" not "Breaking News"
JMS63
7:25 pm on Thursday, November 17, 2011
So what is the help you think we need......lower our IQ points because we are reading The Neighborhood Files instead of Breaking News?
jim laguardia
11:04 am on Friday, November 18, 2011
The kind of help some people need is the profesional kind that will help you with your anger issues and the feeling of being able to hide behind a fake name and bully other people who used their real names in a story about them. The author could have written the same story using "*names have been changed to protect those involved" but they put their name on the line unlike some people who are our to attack others.
Kit
10:55 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011
ps.. Jim Laguardia-- her mothers name is not patty.. i did my research it is debbie parker so the article isn't even complete true facts!
Lynn F.
9:22 pm on Thursday, November 17, 2011
I do agree with some prior posts that some citizens in our society need to bear more responsibility with whatever choices/mistakes they make in life instead of depending on taxpayers handouts. While raising my kids as a single parent, I worked two jobs to pay the bills, lived in a one bedroom (kids had the bedroom, I slept in livingroom) had no amenities i.e. cable TV (I bought used VHS tapes for the girls to watch) and got free videos from the library etc. I ended up working for the woman who owned the daycare where my kids went (part time to help pay off the daycare bill). I used hand me down clothes from my sister in laws and also went shopping at thrift shops....I persevered in court for child support and even had my ex put in jail for nonpayment of child support!!! Tanya, I pray that you continue to work on your issues (dealing with a deadbeat father of the children) and work on any issues derived from being raised in a dysfunctional household so you don't end up passing on major issues to your children... I am far from perfect and will always be working to better myself and enrich my grandchildrens lives...
JMS63
2:42 pm on Friday, November 18, 2011
YOU should have an article written about you and what you have accomplished - THAT would be newsworthy. Thanks for sharing what it means to REALLY take responsibility - especially when others in your life don't.
Melissa
8:00 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011
OK, first of all there are two sides to ever story. I dont care who writes something about you in some unknow paper. Lets start with some fact. Jimmy, Merissa's father has been calling for months trying to see his daughter. Time after time she has shot him down. Not only that but Jimmy's family has also tried to get in contact with her and they have heard nothing. So were are people to come off saying how horrible jimmy is when tanya is the monster that wont let her own daughter see her father and her grand parents.
Second, lets add up all the things tanya has been giving. Jimmys parents gave tanya buick-park ave in excellent condition and she no longer has it. They have bought merissa tons of clothes and toys, and have giving tanya expensive washers, dryers, dishes, and money for storage rooms and such.
Or how about myself. I lived in a homeless shelter, and my newborn baby died due to birth deffects....does that mean i get a story in the danbury patch too??? I now work as a single mom with two kids, making $1200 a week. Were is my acknowledgement?!?!? Does that mean i get a story in the danbury patch too??
There is alot about this women that people do not know. How about the sad fact that Tanya dated a sexual affender for months. Does this not concern the public?? Or are we all going to turn our heads because she gave a child up for adpotion?? Tanya is a sad excuse for a "poster child" to represent mothers giving up their childern.
Melissa
8:40 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011
(Continue)
Were was "patty" in all this?? Isnt she tanya's "parent"? I would do everything I could to make sure that my child would never have to face such a self-less action again. Instead she just steps aside and lets this happen!?
I 100% agree. Tax payers are now paying tanya to sit home on a computer and "play school". If Jimmy stopped paying the rent, then why didnt tanya go out and get a job?? There are tons of families out in the work today were both adults work full time jobs to support the things they need in life.
Jimmy, merissa's father works a full time job and then goes to school at night to futher his life. Inbetween he still finds time to be a family man.
Tanya has done nothing but take from people and leach off people who want to help her. I congratulate the people who have done self-less acts for others. And i only hope people who end up meeting Parker from today on to caution themselves, because you will be used.
Kit
10:48 pm on Monday, November 21, 2011
I am dissapointed in this article. Yes, giving up your child Tanya was hard I am sure but if you had no money then and you have no money now why does it make it better to have kept Merissa? You have not had a job in how long and where are you living and when you ex Jim was working and attempting to pay the bills what were you doing? If this is meant to be a sad story then ok yeah your life is sad. I applaud you for going to school. But for 8 years since CJ was born did you ever stop to think that you needed to be an independent women and provide for yourself rather than use others to provide for you. And this whole the father doesn't want anything to do with his children I highly doubt that as I am sure anyone could call the danbury children's court system and find out that there are letters filled for Jim to have rights to his daughter? I highly doubt the court system would lie! You put yourself in this pickle and I don't commend you for becoming public with your so called "rough life" as you TANYA PARKER cannot blame anyone else for a tough life other than yourself. You have done well with going to school but I will only show excitement when you have followed through with this and are no longer using my hard earned tax money to survive!
JMS63
10:52 am on Tuesday, November 22, 2011
Yes, the facts certainly shed much needed persepective on this situation -all you bleeding hearts can write your checks directly to Tanya so she can suck you dry...I work hard for my money and refuse to let it be squandererd by unemployed slugs like this one without putting up a fight.
Kate
12:08 pm on Tuesday, December 13, 2011
Is this story meant to give all the other unwed, uneducated idiots dating bad men hope for the future? WHY DON'T THESE WOMEN EVER LEARN? It makes me sick. As an educated woman I feel sick when I read about stupid women making bad choices again and again. Pick yourself up, dust yourself off, and stop throwing pitty parties when you mess up. LEARN TO MAKE GOOD CHOICES and stop draining our economy. NO MORE "Oh well" crap.
Star
8:34 am on Sunday, January 29, 2012
Wow, some people are so harsh and judgmental. It is harder to give up a child so he can have a better life than to keep him.You did what was best for him Tanya and I applaud you.