patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

BJ's Wholesale Gets Go-Ahead from Zoning, Expect to Break Ground Next Spring

An application to construct a BJ's Wholesale store and restaurant in the former Fine Arts Theatre complex gained unanimous approval Thursday.

 

Mike Fitzpatrick, the project manager for the proposed BJ’s Wholesale Club and adjoining restaurant in the north section of the Kohl’s shopping plaza on Federal Road, said now that the projects have been approved by the town boards, an application would be submitted within days to the State Traffic Commission (STC) and construction could start by next spring.

“Everybody we dealt with on the town commissions had positive feedback,” he said in an interview Thursday night after the Zoning Commission unanimously approved the application for the 28.8 acres located from 84 to 140 Federal Road.

Brian McCarthy, the civil engineer for the project, said it would include a 124,560-square-foot BJ’s Wholesale Club and a 3,200-square-foot restaurant.

Robert Nagi, the traffic engineer for BJ’s, said the wholesale center and restaurant would generate a combined 5,700 additional vehicle trips to the parcel.

In response to a question from Zoning Commission Chairman Bill Mercer during the public hearing, Nagi said to improve the traffic flow a left turn lane would be added along Candlewood Lake Road to get to Federal Road and a right turn lane from Route 7 onto Federal Road.

Nagi said the timing on the nearby signal lights also would be changed to ease traffic congestion in the area.

The Inland Wetlands Commission approved BJ’s application this last Monday and Richard Papenfuss, the chairman of the Water Source Site Plan Review Committee for the Brookfield Volunteer Fire Company sent a letter to the Zoning Commission this week stating that the panel is “very satisfied” with its plans for fire suppression at the site.

McCarthy said “a new pump house” would be built and connected to the existing 200,000-gallon water tank.

He told the Zoning Commission that three existing buildings would be razed in the north section of the shopping center, which was built in the 1960s to house Caldor’s, which for many years occupied the site where Kohl’s is now located on the southern portion of the parcel.

“It will be totally redeveloped in terms of parking and landscaping,” McCarthy said during the Zoning Commission’s public hearing. “The drainage will be revamped.”

He said plans for a new sewer line that would connect to the system on Candlewood Lake Road would be submitted soon to the Water Pollution Control Authority.

Landscape architect Abigail Adams, of CCA in Brookfield, who is representing BJ’s, said “shade trees and shrubs” would be added to the parking area.

Fitzpatrick said the STC has up to six months to make a decision after an application is submitted, but that it can act in a shorter period of time.

Nagi said BJ’s has had a pre-approval meeting with the STC and “no questions of contention” were raised by the members of the commission.

Fitzpatrick said if BJ’s application is approved, the company would finalize the purchase of parcel with “the seller” and hopefully have construction underway next spring.

He said it would take about 12 months to build the wholesale center.

“It’s a good area for retail,” Fitzpatrick said of the southern corridor of Federal Road, which already generates a steady traffic flow from Costco and several furniture stores.

Lowe’s Home Improvement had considered building a store on the parcel some years ago but instead opted for a location in Danbury.

The owners of smaller retail centers along the southern corridor of Federal Road have said they get many out-of-town customers who come to the area to shop at Costco and the furniture stores, as well as Stew Leonard’s in Danbury.

Economic Development Commission (EDC) Chairman Hal Kurfehs said his panel plans to make a recommendation on BJ’s proposal next Tuesday and he anticipated that it would be favorable since the members have made “very positive comments” about the application.

He was the only person to speak in favor of BJ’s proposal during the Zoning Commission hearing. No one spoke in opposition.

“This is good use of an area that has been wasting away for years,” Kurfehs said of the property, which once housed a movie theater and several small retail stores.

First Selectman Bill Davidson has said he has been impressed with the preparation that BJ’s has put into its application.

Town officials have been seeking to expand the town’s commercial tax base, which has stood for years at about 14 percent of the overall tax revenue.

In addition to the BJ’s Wholesale Center, the town is seeking to develop the 198 acres in the Town District Center along the northern part of Federal Road into a pedestrian-friendly retail streetscape.

Town boards also have approved a retail center on the 37-acre cornfield along Junction Road.

Annmarie Hudson

9:28 am on Friday, April 15, 2011

When are we going to get a new food store in Brookfield. Shoprite is our only option and you cant get a parking space anymore. It is outrageous!!!!!

Reply
Comment_arrow

CT Yankee

7:23 pm on Friday, April 15, 2011

I guess many don't remember that Brookfield did have a grocery store where the BJ's is proposed, called Shopwell. It went out of business. Then there was a grocery store where TJ Maxx is, called Waldbaum's. It also went out of business.

If you're on the Newtown side of Brookfield, near exit 9, both BigY's are pretty close.

Lori

9:55 am on Friday, April 15, 2011

I agree with Annmarie. Shop-Rite has become a madhouse after noon time every day. In fact I know of many people from other towns like New Fairfield and Danbury that also come and shop at Shop-Rite, which really makes the crowding and parking situation that much worse. Why not get a Whole-Foods store?? It is very difficult to find all natural/organic foods in one store. BJ's is a great store, but we already have Costco....not many people shop at Costco for the little food items they consume everyday; BJ's is no different. Oh well...guess it's written in stone now? I think more women need to be making these decisions (no offense), but we are "practical" thinkers and tend to gear our decisions based on NEEDS, not monetary.

Reply
Comment_arrow

David Propper

11:38 am on Friday, April 15, 2011

Lori, we don't "get" any store. We have to create an inviting environment. And remember, most of the issues with this particular site where based upon the current owners and not the town. But each business must make their own decision. Costco wanted to use the corn field and we scared them away from that site (I am not making a judgment). I believe that both genders were well represented in that decision.

In terms of Whole-Foods, they decided to place their shingle at the former Marcus Dairy in Danbury. I agree that it would have been nice to have in Brookfield but that was not meant to be.

Steven DeVaux

10:09 am on Friday, April 15, 2011

With only a fixed amount of retail dollars to compete for, it appears BJ's could drive Costco to Danbury a lot quicker due to traffic and demographic spending concerns. The property near the Danbury Mall will make a perfect easy on/easy off opportunity for Costco to consider now.

In terms of shopping, Brookfield does have the Brookfield Supermarket at Four Corners which is a lot less crowded and has a wide variety of choices. Home Foods is opening a store on the former Marcus Dairy property by the Danbury Mall making it appear more and more that the Danbury Mall area is the one stop shopping retail center to consider with skyrocketing gas prices. If Costco moves there, so will all the NY license plates now on Federal Road.

And remember, Stew Leonards of Danbury is less that a mile down the road.

Who knows what will move into the former Borders store in Danbury besides!

Besides vacuming out the sales dollars at Costco, BJ's will more than likely do a good job of doing it across the street from Shoprite too!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Annmarie Hudson

10:58 pm on Friday, April 15, 2011

Have you been to the store at the four corners lately....if you have, I hope you wouldn't even have mentioned it as an option.

Comment_arrow

Steven DeVaux

8:36 am on Saturday, April 16, 2011

Annmarie,

I hadn't but I'll take you at your word that the store has gone downhill since I last visited, not unlike the entire 4 corners area. That's a shame. Apparently Brookfield has the retail dollars to support only one supermarket. Every time they try and spread them over two, one fails. Same problem will happen with Costco/BJ's. It escapes our elected/appointed officials consciousness that you have to "grow the pie" to feed more. It's happened over and over in the last 10 years. Brookfield has an economic retail base (including draw) of about $300 million.

If Costco is savvy, they understand that half their business is a draw from NY state. BJ's will be closer and less traffic for those folks. For Costco to trump BJ's they have to intercept those retails dollars long before they reach the Federal Road exit of Route 7. Locating on the north side of I-84 between exits 2 and the Danbury Mall will ensure they have a strategic location with a larger store that can attract the NY business as well as Ridgefield, Danbury, New Fairfield, Bethel and Brookfield.

Watch and wait for the move. Probably about two years if they start planning now. It's all about economics and demographics, not wishing and hopeing. Just look at Barnbeck's for an example.

Robin Maynard

10:38 am on Friday, April 15, 2011

If the zoning board approved a retail center on the corn field property, why didn't they approve Costco? Costco is an established business. A retail center is a fancy name for a strip mall. Businesses will come and go and it may end up just like the Joanne's plaza. In my opinion, shame on Brookfield for treating a long time established business terrible and then extending the welcome wagon to the new kid on the block. I welcome BJ's, but what about Costco?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Tim Riddle

3:49 pm on Friday, July 8, 2011

Robin, I agree. For the zoning board ,it's not a gamble.Throw it it up, and see if it sticks.

Tim Riddle

Comment_arrow

Steven DeVaux

7:30 am on Saturday, July 9, 2011

It will be far more interesting to see BJ's and Costco gas stations as the only two in Brookfield after they undercut the price on all the Four Corner gas stations as well as Irving, Shell, Mobil and Sunoco. You know the Chamber of Commerce is going to shrink as they only have donuts, coffee, newspapers, chips and water to sell and pay the rent. Oh yes, and Lotto. Nice hometown businesses run out by two big box stores after a century of roots in the community.

Steven DeVaux

11:34 am on Friday, April 15, 2011

The zoning board has a plan. They can explain it to you here in 300 words or less.

Remember they planned the Four Corners expansion after they championed the Brookfield Bypass?

They have a 10 year plan of conservation and development that they participate in and are just completing in cooperation with the planning commission. This is also part of the strategy of the town's Economic Developement Commission working with the First Selectman's office.

They have a plan to have people in Brookfield spend more. You need to ask them how they are doing that.

Costco is past their prime and they need to spread around the sales a little.

Reply
Comment_arrow

JJV

4:38 pm on Friday, April 15, 2011

Can you possibly explain in 300 words or less what the heck you have said in this comment? There are a lot of people working hard on behalf of the town of Brookfield in an attemt to grow our commercial base in a controlled and logical manner. You on the otherhand do nothing but criticize everyone who proposes any idea and everything that is proposed. Seeing you have all the answers, why don't you step out from the shadows, roll up your sleeves and get busy in a positive way. It's a shame that such talent is being underutilized.

Steven DeVaux

8:40 am on Saturday, April 16, 2011

The town has a plan.

Shssshhhh...it's a secret only shared with certain real estate developers.

Reply

Susan Balla

3:51 pm on Saturday, April 16, 2011

I been in this town since 1952 when I was brought here as a baby. I have seen this town go from 3000 people to 17,000 people. The area that BJ's is going to be used to be a ballfield. Then came Shopwell. Then came the theatre and many little stores with two restaurants. We had Caldor's as an anker store. (I do believe many people still miss this store) then we has Kohl's and I understand that is being closed up. I agree that we need another supermarket. Shoprite needs competition. Not everyone is going to go to BJ's. Not everyone goes to Costco either. I do hope they change the light and the road across from the Shoprite plaza. Poor Brookfield. It use to be just a Parrish.

Reply

Leave a comment